- Subscribe to RSS feeds
- Search
- Categories Index (4,154) Index (4,154) Adult Bible Classes (703) Adult Bible Classes (703) 1 Corinthians (109) 1 Corinthians (109)
 1 John (19) 1 John (19)
 1 Kings (1) 1 Kings (1)
 1 Samuel (12) 1 Samuel (12)
 2 Samuel (11) 2 Samuel (11)
 Acts (46) Acts (46)
 Amazing Grace (69) Amazing Grace (69)
 Apologetics (52) Apologetics (52)
 Blue Parakeet (29) Blue Parakeet (29)
 Creation 2.0 (36) Creation 2.0 (36)
 Faith Lessons by Ray Vander Laan (51) Faith Lessons by Ray Vander Laan (51)
 Galatians (35) Galatians (35)
 John (140) John (140)
 Luke (2) Luke (2)
 Psalms (1) Psalms (1)
 Revelation (16) Revelation (16)
 Sermon on the Mount (42) Sermon on the Mount (42)
 The Story (36) The Story (36)
 
 Bible Study Resources (39) Bible Study Resources (39)
 Blogging (7) Blogging (7)
 Book Reviews (349) Book Reviews (349) Church Refugees (11) Church Refugees (11)
 Covenant: God's Purpose, God's Plan (7) Covenant: God's Purpose, God's Plan (7)
 Gordon Wenham’s Story as Torah: Reading the Old Testament Narrative Ethically (7) Gordon Wenham’s Story as Torah: Reading the Old Testament Narrative Ethically (7)
 Honor & Shame, by Roland Muller (3) Honor & Shame, by Roland Muller (3)
 How God Became King (3) How God Became King (3)
 John Nugent’s Endangered Gospel (9) John Nugent’s Endangered Gospel (9)
 Kingdom Conspiracy by Scot McKnight (21) Kingdom Conspiracy by Scot McKnight (21)
 Misreading Scriptures with Western Eyes (14) Misreading Scriptures with Western Eyes (14)
 Muscle & Shovel, by Michael Shank (32) Muscle & Shovel, by Michael Shank (32)
 N. T. Wright's After You Believe (5) N. T. Wright's After You Believe (5)
 N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began (108) N. T. Wright's The Day the Revolution Began (108)
 Naked Gospel, The (5) Naked Gospel, The (5)
 NT Wright's Surprised by Scripture (1) NT Wright's Surprised by Scripture (1)
 Paul and the Faithfulness of God (22) Paul and the Faithfulness of God (22)
 Sitting at the Feet of the Rabbi Jesus (3) Sitting at the Feet of the Rabbi Jesus (3)
 The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24) The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24)
 The Case for the Psalms, by N. T. Wright (4) The Case for the Psalms, by N. T. Wright (4)
 The Death of the Messiah and the Birth of the New Covenant, by Michael J. Gorman (7) The Death of the Messiah and the Birth of the New Covenant, by Michael J. Gorman (7)
 To Change the World (17) To Change the World (17)
 Vines: God and the Gay Christian (6) Vines: God and the Gay Christian (6)
 
 Christian Disciplines (27) Christian Disciplines (27)
 Christian Evidences/Apologetics (62) Christian Evidences/Apologetics (62) Archaeology (7) Archaeology (7)
 Scientific Creationism (17) Scientific Creationism (17)
 
 Church & Politics (50) Church & Politics (50)
 Church Finances and Business (44) Church Finances and Business (44) Taxes (13) Taxes (13)
 
 Church of Christ Doctrinal Issues (647) Church of Christ Doctrinal Issues (647) Age of Accountability (17) Age of Accountability (17)
 Assembly 2.0 (13) Assembly 2.0 (13)
 Christmas (7) Christmas (7)
 Church of Christ Deism (16) Church of Christ Deism (16)
 Congregational Autonomy and Mergers (22) Congregational Autonomy and Mergers (22)
 Denominationalism (2) Denominationalism (2)
 Discipline (6) Discipline (6)
 Divorce and Remarriage (72) Divorce and Remarriage (72)
 Ecclesiology (24) Ecclesiology (24) Church 2.0 (22) Church 2.0 (22)
 Communion (2) Communion (2)
 Deacons (5) Deacons (5)
 
 Fork in the Road (115) Fork in the Road (115)
 Instrumental Music (129) Instrumental Music (129)
 Real Restoration (52) Real Restoration (52)
 Real Worship (32) Real Worship (32)
 Renewing Our Worship (52) Renewing Our Worship (52)
 Role of Women (91) Role of Women (91)
 Sacramentalism (12) Sacramentalism (12)
 What Must be Preserved of the Churches of Christ? (25) What Must be Preserved of the Churches of Christ? (25)
 
 Church Plants and Foreign Missions (56) Church Plants and Foreign Missions (56)
 Church Trends (67) Church Trends (67)
 Churches of Christ (246) Churches of Christ (246)
 Commenting (13) Commenting (13)
 Communion Meditations (42) Communion Meditations (42)
 Counseling (1) Counseling (1)
 Evangelism (1) Evangelism (1)
 Grace (206) Grace (206) Amazing Grace (103) Amazing Grace (103)
 Facing Our Failure (3) Facing Our Failure (3)
 Faith That Works (24) Faith That Works (24)
 GraceConversation.com (15) GraceConversation.com (15)
 
 Hermeneutics (207) Hermeneutics (207)
 Holy Spirit and Providence (124) Holy Spirit and Providence (124)
 Jewish Roots of Christianity (6) Jewish Roots of Christianity (6)
 Leadership (491) Leadership (491) Adult Bible Classes (9) Adult Bible Classes (9)
 Church Growth (104) Church Growth (104) Direct Hit (6) Direct Hit (6)
 Megachurches (16) Megachurches (16)
 Replanting a Church (28) Replanting a Church (28)
 What's Wrong with How We Do Church (12) What's Wrong with How We Do Church (12)
 
 Church Ministries (29) Church Ministries (29) Small Groups (7) Small Groups (7)
 Spiritual Formation (7) Spiritual Formation (7)
 
 Church Refugees (11) Church Refugees (11)
 Deacons (12) Deacons (12)
 Elders (129) Elders (129) Advice to a New Elder (42) Advice to a New Elder (42)
 Bad Elders (9) Bad Elders (9)
 
 Good to Great (3) Good to Great (3)
 I Sold My Soul on eBay (7) I Sold My Soul on eBay (7)
 Leading a Small Church (3) Leading a Small Church (3)
 Leading Change (31) Leading Change (31)
 Litigation Between Brothers (2) Litigation Between Brothers (2)
 Ministers (31) Ministers (31)
 Multi-generational/Orange Ministry (15) Multi-generational/Orange Ministry (15)
 Multisite Churches (1) Multisite Churches (1)
 Organizing Your Church (7) Organizing Your Church (7)
 Overseeing the Moderate Church (7) Overseeing the Moderate Church (7)
 Preacher Searches (10) Preacher Searches (10)
 Preaching (4) Preaching (4)
 Racial Diversity in Church (10) Racial Diversity in Church (10)
 Sexual Ethics (17) Sexual Ethics (17)
 Teams (2) Teams (2)
 The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24) The Advantage, by Patrick Lencioni (24)
 The Pain of Disappointment (15) The Pain of Disappointment (15)
 Vision (1) Vision (1)
 Worship/Assembly Planning (8) Worship/Assembly Planning (8)
 
 Missional Christianity (129) Missional Christianity (129) Everything Must Change (4) Everything Must Change (4)
 Ministry Ideas (21) Ministry Ideas (21)
 Radical (8) Radical (8)
 Resident Aliens (8) Resident Aliens (8)
 Simply Missional (11) Simply Missional (11)
 
 New Wineskins Magazine (26) New Wineskins Magazine (26)
 Parenting (2) Parenting (2)
 Race (1) Race (1)
 Restoration Movement (55) Restoration Movement (55)
 Sacraments (210) Sacraments (210) Baptism (180) Baptism (180)
 Lord's Supper (34) Lord's Supper (34)
 
 Sexuality (119) Sexuality (119)
 Technology (1) Technology (1)
 Textual studies (591) Textual studies (591) 1 Corinthians (108) 1 Corinthians (108)
 1 John (19) 1 John (19)
 1 Kings (1) 1 Kings (1)
 1 Samuel (13) 1 Samuel (13)
 1 Thessalonians (30) 1 Thessalonians (30)
 2 Samuel (12) 2 Samuel (12)
 2 Thessalonians (18) 2 Thessalonians (18)
 Acts (46) Acts (46)
 Colossians (13) Colossians (13)
 Ephesians (18) Ephesians (18)
 Galatians (40) Galatians (40)
 Hebrews (1) Hebrews (1)
 Luke (10) Luke (10)
 Philemon (2) Philemon (2)
 Revelation (62) Revelation (62)
 Romans (163) Romans (163)
 Sermon on the Mount (42) Sermon on the Mount (42)
 
 Theology (585) Theology (585) Afterlife, The (117) Afterlife, The (117)
 Atonement (54) Atonement (54)
 Available Light (46) Available Light (46)
 Calvinism (107) Calvinism (107) Election (60) Election (60) God Is Not Fair (1) God Is Not Fair (1)
 
 Neo-Calvinism (8) Neo-Calvinism (8)
 Perseverance (12) Perseverance (12)
 Searching for a Third Way (21) Searching for a Third Way (21)
 The Pope, the Salvation of the Jews and Calvinism (16) The Pope, the Salvation of the Jews and Calvinism (16)
 
 Christology (1) Christology (1)
 Connection of Church with Israel (74) Connection of Church with Israel (74)
 Cruciform God (17) Cruciform God (17)
 Gospel, What Is the? (47) Gospel, What Is the? (47)
 Inerrancy and the Canon (14) Inerrancy and the Canon (14)
 Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (6) Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (6)
 New Perspective (19) New Perspective (19)
 Pacifism (29) Pacifism (29)
 Soteriology (103) Soteriology (103) Salvation 2.0 (78) Salvation 2.0 (78)
 The Salvation of the Christians (9) The Salvation of the Christians (9)
 The Salvation of the Jews (16) The Salvation of the Jews (16)
 Universalism (11) Universalism (11)
 
 Story theory (10) Story theory (10)
 Theodicy (How God can allow bad things to happen) (7) Theodicy (How God can allow bad things to happen) (7)
 Truth, What Is? (5) Truth, What Is? (5)
 What Is Sin? (8) What Is Sin? (8)
 
 Thought Questions (83) Thought Questions (83)
 Youth Ministry (10) Youth Ministry (10)
 
 Uncategorized (5,140) Uncategorized (5,140)
 
- Recent Comments- Guy Diffenbaugh on Site Rules
- StavinChain on Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Larry Cheek on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Larry Cheek on CENI: Binding Examples
- Michael on Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Dwight on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight Haas on CENI: Binding Examples
- Stephen Youngblood on CENI: Binding Examples
- Dwight on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Monty on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Larry Cheek on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Mark on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Larry Cheek on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Larry Cheek on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- David on Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- Dwight Haas on “Muscle and a Shovel”: In Reply to the Author, Michael Shank
- Dwight Haas on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- David on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
- Larry Cheek on Will the Ark of the Covenant Ever Be Found?
 
- Top Posts & Pages- Hallelujah, performed with new lyrics by Cloverton
- Ray Vander Laan's "Follow the Rabbi" lectures
- Acts 2: Were the Apostles Baptized in Water? Part 1
- Progressive Church of Christ Blogs, E-Zines, Writings and Groups
- U.S. Income and Employment Taxes for Missionaries (corrected and expanded)
- Communion Meditation: God's Great Banquet
- The Story: The Tabernacle, Worship, and the Christian, Part 1 (Living Sacrifices)
- Born of Water: Don’t we contact the blood of Christ at baptism?
- More Missionaries and Taxes Regarding Housing
- The Holy Spirit: Romans 8:19-27
 
Category Archives: Muscle & Shovel, by Michael Shank
John Mark Hicks Reviews When Shovels Break
Michael Shanks has published When Shovels Break, a sequel to his Muscle and a Shovel, another novelized treatment of his theology. Shanks asked me to read and review his new book, but having spent so much time on Muscle and a … Continue reading
Additional Reviews of Muscle & a Shovel
Muscle and a Shovel by Michael Shank is a self-published book relating the story of his conversion from being a Baptist to a member of the Churches of Christ. It’s gained immense popularity among the more conservative Church of Christ … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: An Open Letter
[Because this is an unusually long post, I’m skipping tomorrow to allow more time for discussion.] We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. (And I guess I did change my mind. What can I say? But this … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel Page
I’ve created a Page that provides a table of contents for all the Muscle & Shovel posts, to make it convenient to read, or refer friends to, this material. A link to the Page will remain available at top of … Continue reading
									
						Posted in Muscle & Shovel, by Michael Shank, Uncategorized					
					
												Comments Off on Muscle & Shovel Page
							
		Muscle & Shovel”: In Conclusion
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. And we are at the end (unless I change my mind). What’s Missing? Shank’s theology has several flaws. 1. It greatly de-emphasizes Jesus in order to emphasize baptism. You can’t … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: Chapters 39 – 40 (Faith in the Plan and the Bible; Wrap Up)
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. Faith = the Plan of Salvation? Back in chapter 35, Shank writes, The Bible definition of faith is belief, repentance, public confession of belief that Christ is God’s Son and … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: Chapter 38, Part 2 (No Creed But Christ)
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. In this post, we consider the history of the Churches of Christ some more. In the 19th Century, the founders of the Restoration Movement, rejected creedalism, that is, the idea … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: Chapters 36 – 38 (Shank is baptized; No creed but the Bible)
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. Shank describes waking his wife up at 11:30 PM to discuss the conversion of Paul and his baptism. “Jonetta, I was baptized for the wrong reason and if that’s the … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: Chapters 31 – 35 (the Spirit)
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. Chapter 31 Shank is close to being re-baptized. Shank and his wife drink some beers, and he gets sick on too much alcohol. Chapter 32 Shank realizes that he smokes … Continue reading
Muscle & Shovel”: Chapter 30, Part 2 (the Real Restoration Movement)
We are considering Michael Shank’s book Muscle and a Shovel. Thomas Campbell, Alexander’s father, in his “Declaration and Address,” stated the aims of the Restoration Movement. It’s generally considered the founding document of the Campbell wing of the Restoration Movement. And it … Continue reading
 
								